Replacing vs. Refacing Kitchen Cabinets: How to Decide Which Option is Best for You

Kitchen cabinets play a significant role not only in how your kitchen looks but also in how it functions. Over time, however, they can begin to look outdated, show signs of wear and tear, or no longer meet your storage needs. Whether you’re embarking on a complete kitchen remodel or a simple makeover, the question of replacing or refacing kitchen cabinets often arises.

 

Here, we’ll explain the differences between refacing and replacing, along with the pros and cons of each option. Then, you’ll be better able to decide which makes the most sense for your own kitchen.

 

What Does the Process of Refacing Kitchen Cabinets Entail?

Picture refacing as a facelift for your cabinets. While the layout and size remain the same, refacing can give outdated-looking cabinets a fresh, new look. Here are the three aspects that get changed when you choose the refacing option:

 

  • Veneer – Existing cabinet boxes get covered with a new veneer, updating the cabinet’s overall appearance.
  • Doors and Drawers – These parts are replaced, giving you an excellent opportunity to significantly change the cabinets’ overall style and look.
  • Hardware – Knobs, handles, or hinges can be updated to further upgrade style, appearance, and functionality.

 

4 Advantages of Refacing Kitchen Cabinets Instead of Replacing Them

If your goal is to save money, time, mess, and waste, refacing could be your best option. That’s because the process offers these advantages:

 

  • Cost-Effectiveness: Refacing your kitchen cabinets will typically cost less than full replacement since the existing structure stays intact and only the exterior is updated.
  • Time Savings: Refacing can usually be completed within a few days, which is much quicker than full cabinet replacement. This can help minimize kitchen downtime and get you back to operations as usual.
  • Less Mess: Refacing is less invasive than a full replacement, resulting in less dust and debris.
  • Eco-Friendly: By reusing the cabinet frames, refacing can be a more environmentally friendly option, reducing waste.

 

When Is Refacing NOT the Best Option?

Replacing your kitchen cabinets may be preferred if:

 

  • Your current cabinets are old and worn. Refacing will not rectify underlying structural damage.
  • The cabinets you currently have no longer meet your needs. Refacing them doesn’t change their function or layout.
  • You’re planning to replace appliances. Newer models may have different dimensions that don’t work with your existing cabinet configuration.

 

What Does Replacing Kitchen Cabinets Entail?

Replacing cabinets involves removing the existing cabinets and installing new ones. This is often part of a larger kitchen remodel but can also be a standalone project.

 

3 Advantages of Replacing Kitchen Cabinets Instead of Refacing Them

  • Customization: You have complete control over the design, layout, materials, and functionality of your new cabinets.
  • Quality and Durability: New cabinets can be made from higher-quality materials, providing improved durability and longevity.
  • Modernization: Updating your kitchen with new cabinets can significantly enhance its overall appearance and value.

 

Key Disadvantages of Cabinet Replacement

  • Cost: Replacing kitchen cabinets is usually more expensive than refacing them. That’s because it involves new materials plus additional labor costs.
  • Time-Consuming: The process takes longer, often several weeks, and can disrupt your kitchen use.
  • More Mess: A full cabinet replacement is a more invasive process, resulting in more dust and debris.

 

How to Decide Between Cabinet Refacing vs. Replacing

Ultimately, the decision of whether to replace your kitchen cabinets or simply reface them is up to YOU. To make the right choice, however, it’s important to ask yourself the following questions:

 

How much money do I want or have to spend?

If your home improvement project is a simple kitchen makeover, there may not be room in the budget for completely replacing your cabinets. On the other hand, if you’re planning an entire kitchen remodel, it will likely make sense to upgrade your cabinets at the same time.

 

What’s the condition of my existing cabinets?

If your current cabinets are structurally sound, refacing them can be a cost-effective way to update your kitchen’s overall look. If they have underlying issues, however, it’s better to replace them.

 

How long can I live without using my kitchen normally?

Cabinet replacement typically takes longer than refacing. If you’re short on time and need your kitchen to be disrupted as little as possible, refacing could be a great option.

 

What’s the ultimate goal of my kitchen upgrade?

If the purpose of your kitchen makeover is to change functionality, update layouts, or upgrade materials and finishes, replacement is the best option.

 

Professional Kitchen Remodeling in Lodi, CA

The bottom line is that both refacing and replacing kitchen cabinets have their merits, with the right choice depending on your specific needs and circumstances. Refacing is a cost-effective, quick, and environmentally friendly option for updating the look of your kitchen. On the other hand, replacing offers more customization, improved quality, and the opportunity to completely transform your space.

 

When you work with the remodeling experts here at Schatz Construction, we can help you decide which option makes the most sense for YOU. From simple kitchen makeovers to elaborate full-kitchen remodels, we have you covered! We’ll help you evaluate your remodeling budget and goals, then implement a plan for breathing new life into your kitchen for a more enjoyable and functional space.

 

Contact us today to learn more or to request a quote!

Ready to start your remodeling project?

Schatz Construction offers Financing Options!

Recent Posts

Recent Posts

Every Detail.  Every Project.  Every Time.